Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility
top of page

Osprey Flyer, Volume XXXVI November/December Edition 2026

Writer: Virginia Osprey Foundation
Virginia Osprey Foundation
2 hours ago
7 min read
Virginia Osprey
Joanie Millward

A Message from the President

As another year draws to a close, we have much to reflect upon and even more to look forward to! It has been a busy and important year for the Virginia Osprey Foundation, filled with educational outreach, conservation efforts, community partnerships, and continued advocacy for the Osprey we all care so deeply about.


In this issue, we will share some important news from the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC), share a new article from our guest writer, and give you a sneak peek at what promises to be an exciting 2027 Virginia Osprey Festival!

And with the holidays just around the corner, we have a little surprise in the works! We are hoping to introduce some exciting new Virginia Osprey Foundation merchandise in time for Christmas. Stay tuned — we think you'll love what's coming!


ASMFC Takes Action — A Step in the Right Direction

After months of public comments, advocacy, and considerable debate, the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission voted in November to reduce both the coastwide menhaden harvest and the Chesapeake Bay reduction fishery cap.


Under the newly approved measures, the Chesapeake Bay cap will decrease from 51,000 metric tons to 37,123 in 2027 and 33,847 in 2028. The coastwide total allowable catch will also be reduced by 9% in each of the next two years.


While these reductions do not go as far as we had hoped, they represent an important step toward recognizing the ecological significance of menhaden and the need to leave more of these vital forage fish in our waters.


The Virginia Osprey Foundation has remained steadfast in advocating for stronger protections for menhaden, a critical food source for Osprey and countless other species. We have witnessed firsthand the devastating decline in Osprey reproductive success in our own community, and we know that much more needs to be done.


We are grateful to everyone who submitted public comments, wrote letters, attended hearings, and made their voices heard. Your efforts matter! This is progress, but our work is far from over. We will continue advocating for science-based management that recognizes the importance of a healthy Chesapeake Bay ecosystem.

A Sneak Peek at Our 2027 Keynote Speaker!

Mark your calendars for Saturday, April 10, 2027!

We are thrilled to announce that David Gessner, acclaimed nature writer, author, and Distinguished Professor at the University of North Carolina Wilmington, will be our keynote speaker at the 9th Annual Virginia Osprey Festival!


David is a passionate observer of the natural world and has written extensively about Osprey, including his celebrated book Return of the Osprey. His writing beautifully captures the connection between wildlife, the environment, and the people who care about both.

Many of you may also recognize David from his powerful article, Hunger Pangs, published in National Audubon magazine earlier this year, which brought national attention to the challenges facing Chesapeake Bay Osprey.


We are delighted that David will be joining us in Colonial Beach to share his experiences, insights, and passion for these magnificent birds.


This is just a taste of what we have planned for April. More exciting festival announcements are coming soon!


From Our Guest Writer


Michael Academia

We are delighted to welcome back Michael Academia, Science Advisor to the Virginia Osprey Foundation, as our guest writer once again!

Michael has been incredibly generous in sharing his time, knowledge, and passion for Osprey with our readers. His thoughtful contributions provide valuable insight into the lives of these remarkable birds and the challenges they face.


We are truly grateful for Michael's continued support of our mission and his willingness to share his expertise through The Osprey Flyer.

Thank you, Michael, for helping us better understand the Osprey we all care so deeply about!


Why Do Ospreys Migrate? Cold Weather, Fish, and the Biology of Leaving


By Michael Academia, MSc Biology, William & Mary


Why do ospreys migrate? Can they tolerate the cold like bald eagles and red-shouldered hawks? Or are they simply following the fish?

As an osprey researcher, I find these questions intriguing and closely connected. To understand why an osprey leaves, we have to consider both the bird’s biology and the conditions that allow it to make a living. Surviving a cold day is one thing, but finding enough food throughout winter is another.


Evolved for fishing

Ospreys eat almost entirely fish. Their talons and hunting behavior are specialized for catching slippery prey. That specialization is impressive, but it comes with a tradeoff; fewer alternatives when fishing becomes difficult.


The distinction I find most useful is between fish being present and fish availability to a hunting osprey. Machmer and Ydenberg (1990) showed that fishing conditions matter: as wind speed increased and the water surface became rougher, hunts lasted longer and were less likely to end with a fish capture. The energetic work required per fish also increased. [1]

For me, this illustrates why the quality of a fishing ground depends on more than the number of fish it contains.


Cold tolerance is only part of the story

I would not interpret migration as proof that ospreys cannot tolerate cold. Some populations spend the winter at temperate latitudes.

Monti and colleagues (2021) combined tracking and isotope evidence to study a Corsican osprey population. They found both residents and migratory individuals. For me, that finding makes an important point: a tropical winter is not a requirement for every osprey. However, it does not mean that every bird could safely remain through a Virginia winter or a much harsher winter farther north. [2]


I also looked for physiological evidence. Rogalla and colleagues (2021) studied heat exchange in ospreys, including behaviors such as panting and wing spreading. Their research helps explain how these raptors release heat, but it does not establish a minimum safe winter temperature or directly compare their cold tolerance with that of eagles and hawks. [3]

The question I come back to is whether an osprey can get enough energy to meet its needs in winter. Cold matters, but so does the reliability of the next meal.


Why can eagles and hawks remain?

When I compare ospreys with bald eagles and red-shouldered hawks, dietary flexibility stands out.

Grubb and Lopez (2000) found that bald eagles wintering in northern Arizona ate mammals, fish, and waterfowl, with their principal foods changing from winter to winter. Eagles have options when fishing conditions deteriorate. [4]


Red-shouldered hawks also eat a wider variety of prey. A long-term study of a year-round resident population in southern Ohio linked breeding timing to temperature and snow cover. The researchers suggested that snow affected access to mammalian prey. Even these resident hunters face winter food-access challenges. [5]


I see these studies as evidence that feeding ecology helps explain different winter strategies. They do not establish that an osprey is less capable of tolerating a particular air temperature.


Following fishing opportunities

So, are ospreys following the fish? I would describe them as moving toward dependable fishing opportunities. Research shows that rainbow trout can shift into deeper habitats as winter progresses. Simpkins and colleagues (2000), for example, tracked juvenile rainbow trout in Wyoming’s Big Horn River and documented a shift from aquatic vegetation to rocky cover in deeper water. Some fish also sought refuge at the bottoms of deep pools during episodes of ice formation, while others sheltered beneath ice in shallow shoreline water. These findings illustrate how winter conditions can change where fish are found. [6]


Along the Atlantic coast, the story includes offshore movements and deep-water schooling. Nesslage and colleagues (2026) documented Atlantic menhaden, a key prey species for Chesapeake ospreys, overwintering 16 – 50 miles off New Jersey. Acoustically measured schools were primarily at depths of 66–98 feet, although some schools occurred closer to the surface. [7]

Map
Figure 1. Winter menhaden schools off New Jersey. Fish icons mark survey sightings; purple triangles mark later sightings. Darker blues indicate deeper water. Adapted from Nesslage et al. (2026).

For me, these findings reinforce the distinction between fish being present and fish being accessible. Deeper or more distant fish could mean fewer feeding opportunities for an osprey hunting near the surface. These studies do not directly explain why ospreys migrate, but they help explain how seasonal changes in fish habitat can shift where these birds can reliably find a meal.


A connection to our Chesapeake research

My own research with Bryan Watts at the Center for Conservation Biology reinforces the importance of food. In our 2023 study, supplemental menhaden feeding improved osprey reproductive performance in the lower Chesapeake Bay. We studied breeding performance, so I would not use that experiment as a direct test of why ospreys migrate. It does, however, show how strongly food supply can influence their success. [8]


When I think about an empty autumn nest, I think about the habitats that sustain their occupants beyond the breeding season. Our responsibility follows them. Protecting ospreys means protecting productive fishing waters at their nesting grounds, migration stops, and winter destinations.


Literature Cited

  1. Machmer, M. M., & Ydenberg, R. C. (1990). Weather and Osprey foraging energetics. Canadian Journal of Zoology, 68, 40–43.

    https://doi.org/10.1139/z90-007

  2. Monti, F., et al. (2021). Using GPS tracking and stable multi-isotopes for estimating habitat use and winter range in Palearctic ospreys. Oecologia, 195, 655–666.

    https://doi.org/10.1007/s00442-021-04855-5

  3. Rogalla, S., Shawkey, M. D., Vanthournout, B., & D’Alba, L. (2021). Thermoregulation and heat exchange in ospreys (Pandion haliaetus). Journal of Thermal Biology, 96, 102857.

    https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtherbio.2021.102857

  4. Grubb, T. G., & Lopez, R. G. (2000). Food habits of bald eagles wintering in northern Arizona. Journal of Raptor Research, 34(4), 287–292.

    https://research.fs.usda.gov/treesearch/24030

  5. Dykstra, C. R., Hays, J. L., Simon, M. M., & Wegman, A. R. (2021). Breeding phenology of Red-shouldered Hawks (Buteo lineatus) is related to snow cover and air temperature during the pre-laying period. Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution, 9, 658390.

    https://doi.org/10.3389/fevo.2021.658390

  6. Simpkins, D. G., Hubert, W. A., & Wesche, T. A. (2000). Effects of fall-to-winter changes in habitat and frazil ice on the movements and habitat use of juvenile rainbow trout in a Wyoming tailwater. Transactions of the American Fisheries Society, 129(1), 101–118.

    https://pubs.usgs.gov/publication/70023166

  7. Nesslage, G., et al. (2026). Biomass and composition of Atlantic menhaden schools in winter on the continental shelf offshore of New Jersey: Application of a novel hydroacoustic survey with midwater trawl sampling. Fisheries Research, 299, 107773.

    https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fishres.2026.107773

  8. Academia, M. H., & Watts, B. D. (2023). Food supplementation increases reproductive performance of ospreys in the lower Chesapeake Bay. Frontiers in Marine Science, 10, 1172787.

    https://doi.org/10.3389/fmars.2023.1172787


Looking Ahead with Gratitude

As we approach the holiday season, we want to express our sincere appreciation to our volunteers, supporters, donors, and community partners. Whether you have given your time, shared your knowledge, contributed financially, or simply helped spread the word about our mission, you are an important part of what we do.


Your support makes our work possible.

If you are considering year-end charitable giving, please remember the Virginia Osprey Foundation. Your tax-deductible donation helps us continue our work in conservation, research, education, and advocacy.


From all of us at the Virginia Osprey Foundation, we wish you and your families a wonderful holiday season and a happy, healthy New Year!

The Virginia Osprey Foundation is dedicated to the protection of Osprey and their habitats through science, education, advocacy, and community engagement, fostering a sustainable environment where Osprey thrive.

 
 
bottom of page